Easy Nun's Puffs

I spent three months thinking nun's puffs were some fancy French pastry I'd never learned to make. Turns out, I'd been making basically the same thing for years and just calling it something different. My neighbor Margaret brought these to a church breakfast last spring, and when I asked what they were, she looked at me like I'd grown a second head. "Nun's puffs, dear. My grandmother made them every Sunday morning." I nodded like I totally knew what she meant, then went home and spent an hour on Google trying to figure out what the heck I'd just eaten.

Here's what they actually are - this old-school American breakfast thing made with choux dough (same stuff as cream puffs) but you bake it in muffin tins instead of piping little rounds on cookie sheets. They puff up huge and go hollow in the middle, get all crispy on the outside but stay soft inside, and you just drizzle honey on them or dump powdered sugar on top.

Old-fashioned American breakfast Nun Puffs made from choux pastry (like cream puffs) baked in muffin tins until golden and hollow inside. Crisp outside, soft inside, and perfect with honey, powdered sugar, or syrup.

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Why You'll Love These Nun's Puffs

I make these nun's puffs baked choux pastry muffins twice a month at least, and it's not because I'm on some vintage recipe kick. It's because Liam realized he can put away four of these for breakfast and I don't feel like a bad mom since they're basically eggs and milk with flour mixed in. They look way fancier than they are, so I can bring them to someone's brunch and people assume I got up at 5 AM baking. Real talk? Fifteen minutes of actual work. Most of that is standing at the stove stirring a pot. The rest is Liam plastering his face against the oven door watching them blow up because he thinks.

What really got me hooked on this best nun's puffs is they're basically foolproof. I've burned chicken, collapsed cakes, made cookies that came out thin as cardboard. These? Work every time. My very first batch came out perfect, which literally never happens when I try something new. The batter doesn't care if you're tired or distracted or whatever - choux dough just nun's puffs up because that's what it does. I've made these while helping Liam with math homework, barely awake on Saturday mornings, completely exhausted after work, and they still look good. And they're done in thirty minutes total. You can't do that with cinnamon rolls or coffee cake or anything else that looks impressive for breakfast.

Jump to:

• Why You'll Love These Nun's Puffs
• Nun's Puffs Ingredients
• How to Make Nun's Puffs
• Equipment for Nun's Puffs
• Storing Your Nun's Puffs (Spoiler: They Don't Keep Great)
• Substitutions
• Nun's Puffs Variations
• Why This Nun's Puffs Recipe Works Every Time
• The Secret: A Full Rolling Boil
• FAQ
• Go Make These Already (Seriously, Stop Reading and Start Baking)
• Nun Puffs

Nun's Puffs Ingredients

The Base:

• Whole milk
• Butter
• All-purpose flour
• Large eggs
• Sugar
• Salt

For Serving:

• Honey for drizzling
• Powdered sugar for dusting
• Maple syrup
• Fresh berries if you're feeling fancy

See recipe card for quantities.

How to Make Nun's Puffs

I've walked about twenty people through this nun's puffs Pioneer Woman style method at this point, and it's way easier than it sounds.

Prep Your Setup First:

• Crank your oven to 400°F and let it actually get hot
• Grab your muffin tin and grease every cup with butter - don't use spray, it doesn't work as well
• Get all your ingredients measured out and sitting on the counter
• Trust me, once you start mixing you don't want to hunt for stuff

Build the Dough Base:

• Toss milk, butter, sugar, and salt into a medium saucepan
• Turn the heat to medium-high and stir occasionally while the butter melts
• Watch for a full rolling boil with big bubbles - not just little ones around the edges
• The second it hits that real boil, yank the pan off the heat immediately

The Flour Dump (Don't Panic):

• Pour all your flour in at once - yes, all of it
• Stir like your life depends on it with a wooden spoon
• It'll turn into this weird sticky ball of dough in maybe 30 seconds
• Keep stirring for another full minute until the dough pulls completely away from the pan sides
• It should look smooth and kind of shiny

Cool Down Period:

• Let that hot dough just sit there for 5 minutes
• Set a timer because I know you'll think it's been long enough after 2 minutes
• If you add eggs too soon they'll scramble and you'll have to start over (did this twice)

Add Eggs One By One:

• Crack your first egg into the dough
• Beat it in completely until you can't see any egg streaks before adding the next
• First egg will make everything look broken and gross - that's supposed to happen
• Each egg makes it look better until the last one makes it smooth and glossy
• If your arm gets tired use a hand mixer on low

Fill Your Muffin Cups:

• Scoop batter into each greased cup about ⅔ of the way up
• Don't overfill them or they'll puff over the sides and make a crusty mess on your pan
• I use an ice cream scoop for this so they're all the same size

Bake Without Peeking:

• Slide the tin into your 400°F oven
• Set a timer for 20 minutes and walk away
• Do NOT open the oven door even though you really want to
• Opening it makes them deflate and there's no fixing that
• They're done when they're golden brown and puffed up huge - takes 20-25 minutes total

Serve Them Hot:

• Pull them out and eat them right away while they're warm
• Drizzle honey all over the tops
• Or shake powdered sugar on them
• Liam dumps maple syrup on his but that's his weird thing

Equipment for Nun's Puffs

• Standard 12-cup muffin tin (the regular size, not mini or jumbo)
• Medium saucepan with a heavy bottom
• Wooden spoon for stirring
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Whisk or regular fork

Storing Your Nun's Puffs (Spoiler: They Don't Keep Great)

Real talk - these homemade nun's puffs variations taste best right out of the oven, and storage is kind of a losing battle. But here's what I've learned from trying anyway:

Same Day (Best Option):

• Leave them on the counter loosely covered with a kitchen towel
• They'll stay decent for maybe 4-5 hours
• After that they start getting chewy instead of crispy on the outside
• Still edible, just not as good

Next Day Storage:

• Put cooled puffs in an airtight container
• Store at room temperature, not the fridge
• They'll be softer and kind of sad looking
• Reheat in a 350°F oven for 5 minutes to crisp them back up a little
• Won't be as puffy but still taste okay

Fridge (Not Recommended):

• I tried this once because I had leftovers
• They got hard and rubbery
• Even reheating couldn't save them
• Liam took one bite and said "Mom, why did you do this to them?"
• Just don't

Freezer (Surprisingly Works):

• Let them cool completely
• Freeze in a single layer on a baking sheet first
• Then transfer to a freezer bag once they're solid
• They'll keep for maybe 2 months
• Reheat straight from frozen at 350°F for 10 minutes
• Not as good as fresh but way better than I expected

What I Actually Do:

• Make exactly as many as we'll eat that morning
• The recipe makes 12, which is perfect for me, Liam, and maybe one or two friends
• If we have leftovers, Liam takes them for snack at school the next day
• He says his friends fight over them even when they're day-old

Substitutions

Milk Options:

• Whole milk → 2% milk (they come out slightly less rich but still good)
• Whole milk → Almond milk (works but tastes a little weird, kind of nutty)
• Whole milk → Oat milk (actually pretty good, Liam couldn't tell the difference)
• Whole milk → Skim milk (don't do this, they come out sad and flat)

Butter Swaps:

• Unsalted butter → Salted butter (fine, just skip the added salt in the recipe)
• Butter → Margarine (technically works but tastes like cardboard, not worth it)
• Butter → Coconut oil (tried this once, they tasted like sunscreen, never again)

Flour Changes:

• All-purpose → Bread flour (makes them chewier, which some people like)
• All-purpose → Cake flour (too delicate, they deflate easier)
• All-purpose → Gluten-free blend (Bob's Red Mill 1-to-1 works okay, not perfect but edible)

Egg Stuff:

• Regular eggs → Extra large eggs (use 3 instead of 4, works fine)
• Whole eggs → Just egg whites (awful, don't try this, they won't puff)
• Room temp eggs → Cold eggs (works but mix slower and don't nun's puffs as much)

Sweet vs Savory:

• Keep sugar, add cinnamon → Good for breakfast
• Skip sugar, add cheese and herbs → Makes them nun's puffs savory style
• Skip sugar, add garlic powder → Really good with soup
• Add lemon zest → Nice for fancy brunch

Nun's Puffs Variations

Cinnamon Sugar Classic:

• Mix 2 tablespoons sugar with 1 teaspoon cinnamon
• Brush hot puffs with melted butter right out of the oven
• Roll them in the cinnamon sugar while they're still wet
• Tastes like churros had a baby with a muffin
• Liam's current favorite, changes weekly though

Savory Cheese Herb:

• Skip the sugar completely in the batter
• Stir in ½ cup shredded sharp cheddar after adding eggs
• Add dried thyme and rosemary to the dough
• Serve these with soup instead of bread
• My sister requests these every time she comes over

Lemon Poppy Seed:

• Add zest of 2 lemons to the batter
• Stir in 2 tablespoons poppy seeds
• Drizzle with lemon glaze instead of honey
• Makes them taste fancy for brunch
• Margaret (my neighbor who introduced me to these) loves this version

Chocolate Breakfast:

• Add 3 tablespoons cocoa powder with the flour
• Increase sugar to 2 tablespoons
• Drizzle with chocolate ganache after baking
• Dust with powdered sugar
• This is basically dessert disguised as breakfast and Liam knows it

Maple Bacon (Liam Named This One):

• Cook 4 strips of bacon crispy, crumble them up
• Stir bacon bits into batter after eggs
• Drizzle with real maple syrup instead of honey
• Tastes like a complete breakfast in one puff
• We make these on his birthday morning every year now

Orange Cranberry Holiday:

• Add orange zest to batter
• Fold in dried cranberries before baking
• Drizzle with orange glaze
• Looks really pretty for Christmas morning
• Made these last December and my mom asked for the recipe three times

Why This Nun's Puffs Recipe Works Every Time

I've made these nun's puffs so many times I can tell you exactly why this recipe doesn't screw up if you do it right. It's not some mystery - it's just chemistry that happens to work out good. When you get that milk and butter boiling for real - not fake simmering, actual big bubbles boiling - the heat does something to the flour starch the second you throw it in. Turns it into that smooth stretchy dough instead of staying all lumpy. Your liquid not hot enough? The flour just sits there not doing anything. And those eggs you're beating in one by one aren't just there to taste good

That 400°F oven makes a ton of steam inside each puff super fast. The outside gets hard and crispy while the inside's still wet and steamy, which is how they end up hollow. You open that oven door to look and all the steam comes out - they fall flat immediately. I literally watched half a batch die when Liam cracked the door at 15 minutes. The ones that weren't set yet survived, the rest looked like deflated balloons. The muffin tin matters too because the batter climbs up the sides as it nun's puffs instead of spreading everywhere.

The Secret: A Full Rolling Boil

My first batch came out flat because I pulled the milk and butter off the heat as soon as I saw a few bubbles. The mixture needs a full, hard rolling boil before the flour goes in. That gets the flour fully cooked into the dough, which is what lets nun's puffs trap steam and rise tall in the oven.

Add the eggs one at a time and beat until each one disappears before adding the next, and keep the oven door closed until they're deep golden.

FAQ

Go Make These Already (Seriously, Stop Reading and Start Baking)

That's the thing about this nun's puffs- it seems so simple that you think it can't possibly matter if you cut corners. But those little details actually make all the difference. The full rolling boil, adding eggs one at a time instead of dumping them all in, not opening the oven door even though you're dying to check on them. Skip any of those and you get flat dense rounds instead of tall puffy gorgeous ones. But follow them exactly once and you'll understand how they work. Then the second batch you make will be even better because you'll know what you're doing. By the third batch you won't even need to look at the recipe anymore.

More pastries that look harder than they are: Lemon Cream Puffs, Homemade Eclairs, Choux au Craquelin, French Beignets and Sopapilla Cheesecake.

Share your nun's puffs with me! I really do look at every photo people send, and Liam gets excited when he recognizes the recipe. If yours come out flat like my first three batches, send that picture too. I'll probably be able to tell you exactly what happened because I've made every possible mistake with these already.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rate this recipe and tell me if you knew what nun's puffs were before this or if you were as confused as I was!