My journey to create the perfect cookie dough ice cream began when Max declared it his "forever favorite" flavor after trying it at our local ice cream shop. Determined to recreate it at home, we embarked on a delicious experiment that took twelve batches to perfect. What makes our version special isn't just the rich vanilla base—it's the way we prepare the cookie dough chunks to stay perfectly soft even when frozen, solving that common problem of rock-hard mix-ins that can break a plastic spoon (or worse, a tooth!).
Why You'll Love This Cookie Dough Ice Cream Recipe
This homemade cookie dough ice cream has become our signature dessert for good reason. After bringing it to family gatherings, neighborhood cookouts, and Max's birthday parties, I've watched ice cream lovers of all ages scrape their bowls clean and come back for seconds. What makes it special is the authentic flavor combination - real vanilla bean in the creamy base paired with generous chunks of chocolate-studded cookie dough that taste exactly like what you'd sneak from the mixing bowl.
Beyond the incredible taste, this recipe is surprisingly practical for busy families. You don't need an expensive ice cream maker to create premium results, and you can prepare both components days ahead of time. The cookie dough uses heat-treated flour and no eggs, making it completely safe to eat while retaining that nostalgic raw cookie flavor. Perhaps best of all, you control exactly what goes into it - adjust the sweetness, the chunk size, or even the mix-ins to create your perfect custom version.
Jump to:
- Why You'll Love This Cookie Dough Ice Cream Recipe
- Cookie Dough Ice Cream Ingredients
- How To Make Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- Substitutions
- Cookie Dough Ice Cream Variations
- Equipment For Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- Storing Your Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- Top Tip
- What to Serve With Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- FAQ
- Homemade Treat!
- Related
- Pairing
- Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Ingredients
For the Ice Cream Base:
- Heavy cream
- Whole milk
- Granulated sugar
- Pure vanilla extract
- Vanilla bean (optional but worth it)
- Fine sea salt
- Egg yolks (for custard base)
For the Safe Cookie Dough:
- All-purpose flour
- Unsalted butter
- Brown sugar
- Granulated sugar
- Vanilla extract
- Salt
- Mini chocolate chips
- Milk (just a splash)
See recipe card for quantities.
How To Make Cookie Dough Ice Cream
After perfecting this recipe through many test batches, here's my foolproof method:
Prep Work:
- Heat-treat flour (bake at 350°F for 5 minutes)
- Cool flour completely
- Gather all ingredients
- Chill mixing bowl
- Set up ice bath
Making Safe Cookie Dough:
- Cream butter and sugars until fluffy
- Add vanilla and salt
- Mix in heat-treated flour
- Add splash of milk for texture
- Fold in mini chocolate chips
- Roll into small balls (marble-sized)
- Freeze for 30 minutes
Creating the Ice Cream Base:
- Whisk egg yolks and sugar
- Heat milk, cream, and vanilla
- Temper eggs with hot cream
- Return mixture to heat until thickened
- Strain through fine mesh sieve
- Cool over ice bath
- Refrigerate until cold (4+ hours)
Final Assembly:
- Churn ice cream base according to machine instructions
- Add cookie dough chunks in last minute of churning
- Transfer to container
- Freeze until firm (4+ hours)
- Let soften 5 minutes before serving
Substitutions
Over years of making this recipe for various dietary needs and preferences, I've discovered these reliable substitutions:
Dairy Alternatives:
- Heavy cream → Coconut cream
- Whole milk → Almond or oat milk
- Regular dairy → Vegan alternatives
- Butter → Plant-based butter
Flour Options:
- All-purpose → Gluten-free blend
- Regular → Almond flour
- Standard → Oat flour
- White → Measure-for-measure GF
Sugar Variations:
- Regular → Coconut sugar
- Granulated → Light brown sugar
- White sugar → Maple sugar
- Standard → Sugar alternatives
Chocolate Options:
- Semi-sweet → Dark chocolate
- Regular chips → Dairy-free chips
- Standard → Cacao nibs
- Chips → Chopped chocolate bar
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Variations
Chocolate Overload:
- Use chocolate ice cream base
- Add dark and white chocolate chips
- Swirl in fudge sauce
- Sprinkle with cocoa nibs
Birthday Cake Edition:
- Add rainbow sprinkles to dough
- Mix in cake batter extract
- Swirl with strawberry sauce
- Top with more sprinkles
PB&J Version:
- Add peanut butter to cookie dough
- Swirl grape jelly through ice cream
- Mix in chopped peanuts
- Top with peanut butter drizzle
Coffee House Special:
- Add espresso powder to ice cream
- Mix coffee extract into dough
- Add chocolate-covered espresso beans
- Finish with caramel swirl
Equipment For Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- Ice cream maker (recommended but optional)
- Baking sheet (for heat-treating flour)
- Instant-read thermometer
- Freezer-safe container with tight lid
- Silicone spatula
- Fine mesh strainer
- Medium saucepan
- Stand mixer or hand mixer
Storing Your Cookie Dough Ice Cream
After making this recipe countless times for eager taste-testers, I've learned these storage tips for the best texture and flavor:
Freezer Storage (Up to 2 Weeks):
- Use shallow, wide containers
- Cover with plastic wrap touching surface
- Secure with airtight lid
- Store in back of freezer (most consistent temperature)
- Label with date
Serving Tips:
- Let soften 5-10 minutes before scooping
- Use a warm ice cream scoop
- Serve in chilled bowls
- Return to freezer immediately after serving
Top Tip
After making dozens of batches of cookie dough ice cream over the years, Max and I discovered the ultimate trick for perfection: size matters when it comes to the cookie dough pieces. Most people make their cookie dough chunks too large, which freeze into hard, teeth-challenging bites, or too small, where they get lost in the ice cream.
The magic size? About the diameter of a regular pencil eraser or small marble. At this size, the cookie dough pieces remain soft enough to bite through even when frozen, but large enough to deliver that satisfying cookie dough experience in every spoonful. We measure this by using a melon baller or teaspoon and then cutting each scoop in half.
Our other game-changing technique is letting the freshly mixed ice cream "cure" in the freezer for at least 24 hours before serving. This resting period allows the cookie dough to slightly soften and release its flavors into the surrounding ice cream, creating a more cohesive dessert where every bite contains hints of that brown sugar, vanilla and chocolate flavor even if you don't get a chunk of dough.
What to Serve With Cookie Dough Ice Cream
This cookie dough ice cream deserves perfect companions that enhance its already delicious flavor. After years of dessert experimentation, we've found that warm pairings create that irresistible temperature contrast that makes ice cream even more special. A fresh-baked chocolate chip cookie or warm brownie underneath a scoop creates that melty edge where the ice cream starts to soften - what Max calls "the magic puddle." For the ultimate experience, try serving it in a heated waffle bowl that stays crisp on the outside but gets slightly chewy where it meets the ice cream.
If you're looking for something simpler, the right sauce can transform a simple bowl into a sundae experience. Warm caramel sauce adds buttery notes that complement the brown sugar in the cookie dough, while classic hot fudge intensifies the chocolate chip flavor. For texture contrast, sprinkle with something crunchy like toasted nuts, chocolate sprinkles, or broken waffle cone pieces - the textural variation makes each bite more interesting.
Don't be afraid of unexpected pairings either! This ice cream makes an impressive layer in trifles, an indulgent filling for macaron sandwiches, or can be scooped over a slice of warm apple pie for the ultimate comfort dessert mashup. At birthday celebrations, we often serve it alongside cake - the cake-and-ice-cream combination is nostalgic and always disappears quickly.
FAQ
What is the cookie dough in ice cream made of?
Cookie dough in ice cream is made with safe-to-eat ingredients including heat-treated flour, butter, sugar, vanilla, and chocolate chips, but no eggs. Commercial versions use pasteurized ingredients and special formulations to maintain softness when frozen, while homemade versions treat raw flour to kill potential bacteria.
Can you eat raw cookie dough ice cream?
Yes, you can safely eat the cookie dough in cookie dough ice cream. Both commercial and properly made homemade versions use heat-treated flour and no eggs, eliminating the usual raw cookie dough risks. In our recipe, we bake the flour at 350°F for 5 minutes to ensure it's completely safe.
Does Baskin Robbins sell cookie dough ice cream?
Baskin Robbins does sell cookie dough ice cream as one of their regular flavors. Their version features vanilla ice cream with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough throughout. They also occasionally offer limited-edition variations like chocolate cookie dough or cookie dough with additional mix-ins.
Why does cookie dough ice cream taste so good?
Cookie dough ice cream tastes so good because it combines two beloved treats - ice cream and raw cookie dough - creating a perfect contrast of temperatures and textures. The sweet, buttery cookie dough chunks provide a satisfying chew against the cold, smooth ice cream, delivering both nostalgic comfort and indulgence in every bite.
Homemade Treat!
Now you have all the secrets to creating perfect cookie dough ice cream at home - from properly heat-treating flour to Max's special cinnamon trick. This beloved dessert proves that sometimes the best treats are the ones we make ourselves, with exactly the amount of cookie dough we want in each bite!
Looking for perfect pairings? Our Easy Snickerdoodle Cookies Recipe offers warm cinnamon notes that complement this ice cream beautifully. For a striking color contrast, try our Easy Red Velvet Cookies with their rich cocoa flavor. Or for something completely different, our The Best Key Lime Cookies provide a tangy citrus contrast that cuts through the sweetness of the ice cream.
Share your cookie dough ice cream creations! We love seeing your frozen treats!
Rate this Cookie Dough Ice Cream and join our dessert-making community!
Related
Looking for other recipes like this? Try these:
Pairing
These are my favorite dishes to serve with Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Equipment
- Ice cream maker (Optional but recommended)
- Baking sheet (For heat-treating flour)
- Instant-read thermometer (For custard base)
- Freezer-safe container (With tight-fitting lid)
- Silicone spatula (For stirring and scraping)
- Fine-mesh strainer (For a smooth base)
- Medium saucepan (For heating custard)
- Stand or Hand Mixer (For creaming dough)
Ingredients
Ice Cream Base:
- 2 cups Heavy cream
- 1 cup Whole milk
- ¾ cup Granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon Vanilla extract
- 1 Vanilla bean - Optional, split and scraped
- ¼ teaspoon Fine sea salt
- 5 Egg yolks
Safe Cookie Dough:
- 1 cup All-purpose flour - Heat-treated
- ½ cup Unsalted butter - Softened
- ½ cup Brown sugar - Packed
- ¼ cup Granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon Vanilla extract
- ¼ teaspoon Salt
- ¾ cup Mini chocolate chips
- 1 tablespoon Milk - Add more if needed
Instructions
- Heat-treat flour at 350°F for 5 minutes, then cool completely
- Cream butter and sugars until fluffy
- Add vanilla and salt
- Mix in heat-treated flour
- Add splash of milk and fold in chocolate chips
- Roll dough into small balls and freeze
- Whisk egg yolks and sugar
- Heat milk, cream, salt, and vanilla
- Temper egg mixture with warm cream
- Cook custard until thickened
- Strain custard and cool over ice bath
- Chill custard in refrigerator
- Churn ice cream base
- Add cookie dough chunks during last minute of churning
- Transfer to container and freeze until firm
- Let soften before serving
Leave a Reply